Bristol Rovers player ratings after 'delight' 8/10 and six 6/10s leave Gasheads solemn in goalfest defeat
Steve Evans’s side will hope to bounce back away at Cambridge next week
Bristol Rovers welcomed Chesterfield to the South West with history firmly on their side, unbeaten in 18 home league meetings against the Spireites and having never lost to them in BS7. In fact, Chesterfield’s only victory away at Rovers across 20 visits came back in 1965 in the League Cup, a statistic that underlined the scale of the task facing the visitors.


The fixture also carried an intriguing managerial subplot, with Steve Evans and Spireites boss Paul Cook meeting for the sixth time in their managerial careers. Evans arrived holding the edge in the head-to-head record, having won three of the previous five encounters to Cook’s two. Rovers were also seeking a measure of revenge after the first meeting of the 2025–26 campaign, when Chesterfield ran out 3-1 winners against a ten-man Gas side managed by Darrell Clarke. Joel Senior’s first-half red card proved pivotal that day, with the recently departed Isaac Hutchinson netting Rovers’ only goal and Kyle McFadzean, Tom Naylor and Armando Dobra finding the net for Cook's side.
Memories of the last league meeting at The Memorial Stadium in 2017, a 2-1 home win for Rovers, added further context, with Tom Lockyer the only remaining player from that victorious side. With Rovers looking to edge closer to safety, another home win potentially moving them ten points clear of the relegation zone and Chesterfield aiming to revive a play-off push after just one win in their last seven, there was plenty riding on proceedings in BS7 after Evans’ cautionary note that his side were “far from safe.”
Steve Evans named an unchanged eleven following the Gas’ impressive 2-0 victory over Walsall in midweek, crucially keeping goalscorers Kofi Balmer and Tottenham loanee Yusuf Akhamrich in the starting lineup after both made telling contributions on Tuesday night at the Memorial Stadium. The Rovers boss opted to freshen things up around them, tweaking his side once more as he looked to build momentum from that eye-catching home win.
Paul Cook, meanwhile, also shuffled his pack, making two changes from Chesterfield’s last outing, which also came against Walsall in a 2-2 draw, as he sought a response following that contest. The Spireites boss was a keen observer at The Mem in midweek, watching Rovers dismantle the Saddlers from the stands, and his selection reflected both that scouting mission and the importance of the occasion.
And from a delayed kick off, It was the away side who struck first inside three minutes, as a lofted ball into the Rovers box found the head of Manderville. He nodded it back across the penalty area where Naylor was waiting, once again haunting the Gas this season as he headed home to give Chesterfield the lead.
Moments later, the Spireites almost doubled their advantage when a dangerous cross picked out Lee Bonis, whose first-time volley was brilliantly kept out by Rovers’ number one, Brad Young. Chesterfield continued to threaten, with another gilt-edged chance falling their way after former Spurs forward Dilan Markanday danced past the Gas defence with superb close control before firing a low, driven cross across goal. However, Manderville was unable to make decisive contact, and another promising opening went begging.
Momentum then swung in Rovers’ favour. As the hosts began to apply pressure, it was a recycled ball from a corner that brought them level. The delivery was launched back into the box, where Shaqai Forde rose highest to plant a pinpoint header into the far corner of Zach Hemming’s net.
Just before the interval, Chesterfield had a golden opportunity to regain the lead on the counter. Bonis slid the ball through to Sammy Braybrooke, but the 21-year-old failed to hit the target when clean through on goal.
Early in the second half, the visitors came close again. Young rushed off his line to deny Bonis, only for the loose ball to fall kindly to Dylan Duffy. However, his effort was dramatically cleared off the line by Gas defender Balmer.
But it was the home side who edged ahead midway through the afternoon, as Forde grabbed his second of the game. A knock-on from debutant Quigley fell invitingly to the 21 year old on the right-hand side of the box, and the winger showed great composure to guide a left-footed finish into the back of the Chesterfield net.
However, the away side responded almost immediately. Chesterfield levelled just minutes later as Naylor completed his own brace, compounding misery for Rovers yet again this season with an excellent looping header that left Young with no chance. The ball drifted into the far corner, sparking wild celebrations among the Spireites supporters in the away end.
The visitors almost capitalised on their momentum as a dangerous delivery to the back post saw Bonis head the ball back across the goal. Manderville looked certain to score from close range, but Gas number one Brad Young produced another heroic save to deny the Spireites right in front of goal.
However, much to the dismay of Gasheads, the away side did find the winner with an expertly delivered cross from full-back Sam Curtis, picked out substitute James Berry at the back post, and the forward, fully stretched, met it with a superb volley into the far corner, adding another moment to this afternoon’s goalfest.
This defeat sees Evans’ side six points clear of the relegation zone, after Newport County as they take a trip to Cambridge United next weekend in an attempt to provide some breathing room from Newport County in their bid to play another season in the division.
Starting Lineup
Brad Young (GK): The keeper was making his fifth start in a row and couldn’t make it 3 home clean sheets. Was caught in two minds for the first goal with a good ball to the back post that meant he couldn’t decide to come and clear. The second goal was a clever looping header that was just a bit too high for him, and the third goal, Young was just wrong-footed by a clever finish. 6.5
Kofi Balmer: The versatile player aimed to follow up on his remarkable goal against Walsall four days earlier. Today, there was another goal involvement for the Motherwell loanee as his delightful flick found Forde for his goal. 7
Riley Harbottle: The signing from Wimbledon continued his record of starting every game since arriving in BS7. Today, he had a tough test marking the dangerous Lee Bonis, and it was a good 50/50 battle between the two. Had a great clearance off the line at 1-1, but that ultimately ends up in vain. 7
Alfie Kilgour (C): The skipper once again led the backline for the third time at the Memorial Stadium after a slight injury had kept him out of the MK Dons game. The visitors played a lot of on-the-ground football today, so it was a different game than it was against Walsall, but Kilgour played ok. Later on, when Chesterfield did go long ball method, Rovers struggled to deal with it, and that has cost them today. 6.5
Jack Sparkes: Making his 27th start of this season, and today had another lung-busting performance up and down the left wing. Didn’t have a huge amount of success with his overlapping runs. Had a few set-piece deliveries from the left that caused the Chesterfield defence trouble. 6
Clinton Mola: Mola continued his run of games staring in the midfield role alongside De Haviland. It was another performance that continued to show that the midfield is definitely Mola’s best position, and he shouldn’t return to left back unless there’s an injury crisis. 6.5
Ryan De Haviland: The midfielder was making his sixth consecutive start in a Bristol Rovers shirt after arriving from League One side Peterborough. Continues to look like exactly what Bristol Rovers needed in the midfield and is giving Rovers fans a lot to be excited about for the rest of the season. 7
Double Delight
Shaq Forde: Forde is on by far his best run in a Bristol Rovers shirt and backed up his manager’s comments from Tuesday with two goals today. Two instances today where Forde got himself into the right place at the right time to grab his second and third goals of the season and continue his recent excellent form. 8
Yusuf Akhamrich: The Tottenham Hotspur loanee made his first start in a Bristol Rovers shirt without a goal; however, it was a solid Performance from the Moroccan youth star. Showed a good balance of going forward and getting back from his right-wing back role. Got the Rovers fans out of their seats a few times, especially with a brilliant dribble he had going from his own half to the Chesterfield box. 7
Ellis Harrison: Harrison was making his 234th appearance for Bristol Rovers tonight. It seemed that Evans didn’t have him doing as much hold-up play as Tuesday night, and therefore, Harrison wasn’t in the game as much today. 6.5
Fabrizio Cavegn: The Swiss striker has now gone consecutive home games after notching his 10th of the season againstNewport County. Despite that, the effort of Cavegn couldn’t be questioned as always. He chased every long ball, got himself in behind the Chesterfield backline several time and was always an option to get the ball to. 7
SUBSTIUTIONS:
Joel Senior: Senior made his 15th appearance of the season, which has been a mix of subs and starts. He came on in added time, so he didn’t have a lot of time to make an impact, but he put a shift in to try and help Rovers get a point, but they ultimately couldn’t. 6
Mees Rijks: The Dutchman made his fourth Bristol Rovers appearance. Had a bit of time to try and make himself a problem with his physicality, but was neutralised by the defence. 6
Tommy Leigh: First Rovers game for Leigh, and he struggled to properly get into the game. Did try constantly but struggled to get the ball in dangerous places. 6
Joe Quiqley: The striker, who was signed from Oldham on deadline day, marked his Bristol Rovers debut with an assist for the second goal. He used his height to knock a ball down for Forde to comfortably slot home, and it shows encouraging signs for the future. 7
Richie Smallwood: The veteran midfielder made his Bristol Rovers debut today, and he showed what he will bring to this team. A knowledgeable player on the pitch, he can confidently drop deep to pick the ball up and keep it moving. It was a solid cameo from Smallwood. 6.5