I asked AI to name Bristol City's worst XI of all-time - this was its frankly brutal response
Bristol City are targeting promotion to the Premier League from the Championship
Bristol City are sat in 7th place in the Championship table as they eye promotion to the Premier League. They won 2-1 at home to Norwich City last time out before the international break.


Liam Manning’s side are only outside the top six on goal difference behind West Brom. The Robins have eight fixtures left to play this season.
They are back in action next weekend away at Burnley. In the meantime, we have asked AI (Grok) to name their worst XI of all-time and this was the response...
Goalkeeper and defenders
Starting in goal, Rene Gilmartin played for Bristol City from 2019 to 2021 but didn’t feature. AI has said: “Signed in 2019 as a backup goalkeeper, Gilmartin made only a handful of appearances and never established himself as a reliable option. His time at Bristol City was unremarkable, and he’s often remembered as a peripheral figure during his stint, failing to challenge the first-choice keepers effectively.”
Richard Keogh joined the Robins in his early career but was loaned out four times . AI has said: “His spell at Bristol City was marred by poor performances, and he failed to shore up a defense that struggled during his tenure.”
Ashley Williams ended his career at Ashton Gate after playing 33 games . AI has said: “Joining in 2019 as a seasoned Premier League veteran, Williams was expected to bring stability. Instead, his time was marked by errors, including a notable own goal in a 3-0 loss to Luton Town, and he lasted only one season before departing.”
Aden Flint was a good servant to Bristol City so his inclusion is a surprise. AI has said: “His mobility, never his strongest asset, had noticeably diminished, leaving him exposed against quicker, more agile forwards.”
Louis Carey had two spells with the Robins. AI has said: “Carey is a Bristol City legend with over 600 appearances, but in his final seasons (around 2013-2014), age caught up with him. His performances declined, and he was part of a struggling side relegated to League One, making him a candidate for this list in that specific context.”
Midfielders
Lee Tomlin scored 13 goals in 60 games for Bristol City before leaving for Cardiff City. AI said: “Signed in 2016 with a reputation as a flair player, Tomlin’s time at Bristol City was underwhelming. Fitness issues and inconsistency plagued his spell.”
Bobby Reid rose up through the academy ranks and now plays in the top flight for Leicester City. AI said: “Before his breakout 2017-18 season, Reid had a rocky start at Bristol City. In his early years (2011-2015), he was often ineffective and failed to secure a regular spot, with fans questioning his potential until his later transformation.”
Former Millwall man Marvin Elliott left in 2014. AI said: “Elliott was a solid midfielder from 2006-2011, but after a severe Achilles injury, his form dipped significantly. His final seasons (2012-2014) saw him struggle to regain his physicality, and he was part of the team that slid into League One.”
Korey Smith had six years with the Robins and is now at Cambridge United. AI said: “Smith was generally reliable from 2014-2020, but recurring injuries in his later years reduced his effectiveness. During these spells, he couldn’t replicate his earlier impact, and his inclusion reflects those frustrating patches.”
Attackers
Nicky Maynard was snapped up by Bristol City as a youngster from Crewe Alexandra. AI has said: “Maynard was a prolific scorer from 2008-2011, but after a serious knee injury in 2011, his form plummeted. His final months at Bristol City before leaving in 2012 were lackluster, tarnishing his earlier legacy.”
David Clarkson joined the Robins in 2009 from Motherwell. AI has said: “Signed from Motherwell in 2009 for £800,000, Clarkson was a major flop. He failed to justify his price tag or adapt to the Championship, and was quickly offloaded.”