Bristol City player ratings as ‘dominant’ 10/10 and five 8.5/10s see Robins fans joyful in 5-1 Watford win

FA Cup action returned to Ashton Gate as Bristol City make fourth round of the FA Cup after 5-1 win against Watford.

Last season the Robins were drawn against Premier league opposition in the form of Wolves and gave a good account of themselves but ultimately fell 1-2.

placeholder image
Getty Images

Before today, Bristol City have won five of their last 20 meetings with Watford at Ashton Gate, giving them a 25 per cent home win rate against the Hornets across the last 35 years and drew 1-1 with the Hornets earlier in the season.

Gerhard Struber made five changes to the starting line up that fell 0-2 to Preston on Sunday. Sam Morsy, Sam Bell, Emil Riis, George Tanner and Joe Lumley came into the starting XI with Sam Morsy making his full Bristol City debut.

It was a fast start from City with Danish striker Emil Riis putting the Robins in front after getting on the end of Neto Borges deep cross to the back post and steering it past Nathan Baxter in the visiting goal.

Watford did have a few half chances after that with striker Semedo having a few nearly chances but either slipping or not hitting the ball in the box after good play on the wings.

Then in the 37th minute, a beautiful team goal finished by Anis Mehmeti doubled City’s advantage. It starts with Vyner doing very well to keep the ball in play right by the touchline and find Jason Knight. The skipper then slipped a lovely ball through to Emil Riis and the Danish striker added an assist onto his earlier goal by squaring to Mehmeti who easily finished into an empty net and made it 2-0.

The second half was quite similar with the Robins constantly on the front foot and they were rewarded with another two goals.

The third goal came from a wonderful Scott twine set piece and it landed perfectly on the head of Rob Atkinson who easily finished past Nathann Baxter and made it three for the Robins.

The fourth came from a moment of brilliance from an unlikely source in Joe Lumley. City’s ‘keeper fired a picture perfect ball to find Neto Borges in behind the Watford defense. Neto then found Emil Riis for the second time in the game and Riis made it 4-0 with a lovely finish.

The visitors pulled one back thanks to substitute Jack Grieves, however any possible momentum was shut down two minutes later.

Emil Riis bagged the first Bristol City hat-trick in over four years and made it 5-1 in the process. He ran onto the end of a chipped ball by returning loanee George Earthy and then dinked the ball over the Watford keeper to seal City’s place in the fourth round.

Bristol City ratings vs Watford

Joe Lumley: A change in between the sticks saw City’s number two come in for Max O’Leary, marking his third appearance of the season, and surprisingly made the most impact in the attacking area of the pitch with an unbelievable long ball to set up City’s fourth goal of the evening. 8

Rob Dickie: The former QPR defender had a miserable return to the starting lineup on Sunday, but a difficult task this evening to stop in-form Watford seemed easy for the 29 year old, showing his class throughout the match as he became the heart of the City back line. 8.5

Zak Vyner: The Kenyan International was the only player in City’s squad to feature in their last FA Cup tie against Watford, and after coming under scrutiny for a defensive error on Sunday, the defender made amends as he grew into his new wing-back position seeing himself grab an assist for The Robins’ second goal of the evening. 8.5

Rob Atkinson: Having been troubled by Preston on Sunday, the defender was taken off early in the second half and again had his hands full dealing with Hornets midfielder Imran Louza, who has registered the most goal contributions this season for the away side, but this time around, the 27 year old displayed an attacking threat himself as he picked up The Robins’ third goal in tonight’s FA Cup thriller. 8.5

George Tanner: The defender, who previously started in both of City’s cup fixtures this season, aimed to make an impact in what Robins fans hope to be a strong FA Cup run after such a dominant performance against fantastic opponents, and the 26 year old only solidified what was a strong defensive display. 8

Neto Borges: The Brazilian has emerged as a standout performer for Struber, earning his 15th start of the season this afternoon, delivering a fantastic assist for Riis’ opening goal, and picking up another assist later in the game. The 29 year old showed why he continues to be a key part of the City boss’s plans as the club reportedly look to sign the wing-back permanently from Middlesbrough. 8.5

Sam Morsy: Having made his debut in City’s last home fixture against Preston, the midfielder appeared in need of more game time, which the Robins boss granted to the Egyptian international this evening, and he certainly made it count as he showed his Premier League experience to be of value. 8

Jason Knight: Since returning from an adductor injury, the captain has been in excellent form, complementing Randell to form a strong partnership of late, but the dynamic duo were split this afternoon, seeing January signing Morsy introduced into the starting eleven, and the two worked seamlessly together, shutting any danger posed in the middle of the park by the away side. 8

Sam Bell: The City graduate was handed his first start since his return from a successful loan spell at Wycombe Wanderers, where he was ever-present throughout the 90 minutes showing great energy, making fantastic runs in behind the away defence, but unfortunately was unable to add his name to the scoresheet in tonight’s goal fest. 8

Anis Mehmeti: The Albanian may have had a quiet outing last time out against Preston, but still marks himself as City’s key threat, adding another goal to his campaign, sitting top in the club’s ranks for goal involvements this season. 8.5

Emil Riis: After featuring off the bench in a damning loss to his former side on Sunday, the Danish forward produced three excellent finishes adding to his tally of ten goals this season, overtaking Mehmeti as the club’s top scorer. The forward also picked up an assist to round off a fantastic performance which saw him grab a first career hat-trick in four years. 10

Bristol City player rating vs Watford - substitutes

Yu Hirakawa: The Japan international has been Struber’s most effective substitute this season, featuring in the starting lineup just four times, one of those starts resulting in a goal in a cup competition, and when he came on, City had already found themselves 4-1 up , although he still produced a great performance to go alongside a fantastic win . 7

Sinclair Armstrong: Failing to register a goal against Preston, it has been clear to see that the Irishman has been most effective as a substitute this campaign, highlighted by a brace from the bench against Portsmouth, and he only added to Watford’s nightmares with his energy and pace in behind which saw the home side cruise to a remarkable 5-1 victory. 7

Adam Randell: Following another impressive display at the weekend, the Reds midfielder continued his ever-present run this season and underlined the depth of quality available to Struber, helping the home side build on an already dominant performance. 7.5

George Earthy: Announced as City’s most recent January signing, the West Ham loanee could hardly have asked for a better second debut for the club. The 21 year old made an immediate impact by providing an assist, adding to an impressive all-round home display for the Reds. 7.5

Scott Twine: Continuing to showcase his creative influence, the Reds’ number 10 once again proved a constant threat to the visitors. After scoring in the 1-1 draw at Vicarage Road last time out, Twine added another assist this afternoon, taking his tally to seven for the campaign. 7.5

Related topics:
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice