Bristol City player ratings vs Sheffield United: 4/10 'shocker' but '6/10 'badly missed' in 3-0 defeat

RED CARD: Bristol City's Rob Dickie (right) walks off after being sent off (Image: Andrew Matthews/PA Wire)placeholder image
RED CARD: Bristol City's Rob Dickie (right) walks off after being sent off (Image: Andrew Matthews/PA Wire)

Bristol City player ratings and scores from the 3-0 defeat by Sheffield United in the EFL Championship play-off at Ashton Gate.

Bristol City’s return to the play-offs after a 17-year wait was spoiled ended in tears for the West Country club.

The Yorkshire seized control of their Sky Bet Championship play-off semi-final by beating 10-man Bristol City 3-0 at Ashton Gate.

Goals from Harrison Burrows, Andre Brooks and Callum O’Hare gave the Steel City side a probably impregnable cushion after a brilliant performance.

Liam Manning made one change from the dramatic draw against Preston which secured the play off space just five days ago. Anis Mehmeti replaced Scott Twine in a like-for-like change out on the left to partner with Nahki Wells to make up City’s attackforce. This was the Albainan’s first start at home since the win over Norwich City in early March.

With Bristol City fans, especially section 82, creating a cauldron of noise the players responded to it with a fast tempo start but no chances. The game then kicked into gear when Sheffield United forward Rihan Brewster thought he put the blades in the lead however the linesman made a very late decision to rule the goal out for offside.

Although Brewster was onside the linesman deemed that Sydie Peck was offside and he blocked City skipper Jason Knight’s ability to get back and clear the ball. That woke the home side up and City had their first chance of the game through a thunderbolt from Joe Williams. Good work from Mehmeti led to the Albanian putting a ball across the outside of the box and it landed on the right boot of Williams.

Unfortunately for the home crowd the ball smacked against the crossbar and bounced away to safety much to the delight of the travelling Sheffield United fans behind the goal. That was one of Williams’ last actions for the game as not long after that Williams went down with what looked like an ankle injury which brought an end to his game and more than likely season as well.

After that the game seemed to stagnate a bit with limited chances for both sides, until just before half time. A searching ball found Tyrese Campbell and his flick-on was run onto by his strike partner Kieffer Moore and just as Moore was about to unleash a shot from inside the box, Rob Dickie was judged to have brought him down which meant a penalty for the visitors and a red card to Dickie’s game and potentially season. Harrison Burrows stepped up to take the penalty and sent Max O’Leary the wrong way and gave the Sheffield side the lead just before half time.

Paying the penalty

Coming out for the second half, the Robins knew they needed a fast start however the spark from the first half had disappeared with the sending off and goal. City found themselves chasing shadows for large parts of the second half with the visitors often stringing together long passages of play and setting up attacks that way. After 73 minutes the visitors doubled their advantage thanks to a goal from substitute Andre Brooks.

Goalscorer for the first, Burrows turned provider as his cross was dummied by Callum O’Hare and Kieffer Moore before it found its way to Brooks and his powered home to just beat O’leary who tried to get across the full length of his goal to stop the shot.

City had a good chance not long after when after good work down the wing the ball eventually landed to Mehmeti but unfortunately for City it landed in the arms of the keeper.

Two turned into Three just over five minutes later, when from a Hamer corner, O’Hare tried to jump out of the way of a shot by De souza, However on his way down his studs connected with the ball and it ended up in the back of the net to spark more jubilant scenes in the away end.

The final score leaves Bristol City needing Three goals and a miracle in the reverse fixture at Bramall Lane on Monday to have any chance of advancing to wembley.

Bristol City player ratings

Max O’Leary – 6. A largely assured performance from the Reds’ number one, who made several important saves to keep City in contention. However, he may feel disappointed with the Blades’ second goal, and despite his efforts, conceding three leaves the South West side with a tough task ahead.

George Tanner – 5.5. Tanner showed ambition and drive, especially when pushing forward after City were reduced to ten men. Despite moments of promise, the defence ultimately struggled to hold firm, particularly during the Blades’ second-half surge.

Rob Dickie – 4.5. Looked composed in the early stages, but his sending off just before half-time - following a shocker of a mistimed challenge on Kieffer Moor— proved pivotal. The red card handed a major advantage to the visitors and swung the game in their favour.

Zak Vyner – 5.5. Vyner brought a calming influence and showed composure with some excellent distribution in the first half. However, as the second half wore on, the defensive line faltered under pressure, adding to City’s mounting challenge.

Ross McCrorie – 5.5. Defensively sound and worked tirelessly after the sending-off, offering himself as an outlet down the right. Yet, unlike his performance against Preston, the Scotsman couldn’t assert himself in attacking areas.

Driving forward

Joe Williams – 6.5. Started brightly, offering energy and bite in midfield before an injury forced him off prematurely. His absence was felt as the game progressed.

Jason Knight – 6. Knight did well to help City retain possession during spells of the game and tried to drive the team forward. However, a resolute Blades defence limited his attacking influence.

Max Bird – 6. Provided control and neat distribution, particularly in deeper areas, but lacked the creative spark to unlock a compact and disciplined opposition back line.

Yu Hirakawa – 5.5. Operating as a wing-back, Hirakawa brought energy and intent down the right flank. Though he tried to inject pace into the game, the Blades largely contained his threat.

Anis Mehmeti – 5.5. Found it difficult to carve out clear chances but remained a persistent threat, especially in the first half. His willingness to get on the ball was evident, though the end product was limited.

Nahki Wells – 5.5. The experienced forward struggled to impose himself and lacked his usual sharpness. The Blades’ disciplined back line allowed him little room to operate.

Substitutes

Haydon Roberts – 5. Introduced at half-time, Roberts couldn’t replicate the impact he made against West Brom and remained largely on the periphery.

Marcus McGuane – 5. Brought on to add fresh legs in midfield, but failed to significantly influence proceedings as the visitors began to dominate.

George Earthy – 5.5. Came on for the injured Williams and showed courage on the ball, but couldn't produce a defining moment this time around.

Sinclair Armstrong – 5.5. Replaced Wells at the break, but like his predecessor, struggled to find space or meaningful opportunities to affect the game.

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice