'Unacceptable traffic' - Council hopes plans to turn ex Bristol care home into two huge houses are refused
Bristol City Council is urging government planning inspectors to refuse permission to turn a former care home in Fishponds into two huge shared houses.
As previously reported, neighbours have objected to the proposed conversion of Chasefield House, Fishponds Road, into a total of 19 bedsits because of fears about pedestrian safety and parking problems. Now the local authority’s planning officers have echoed those concerns and are recommending that the redevelopment is rejected.


The two houses in multiple occupation (HMOs) – one a 10-bed and the other nine – would be operated by Creative Independent Living, which provides accommodation and support for vulnerable people on behalf of the city council’s social services.
The organisation has bypassed the council’s planning department, which is in special measures, and submitted its application directly to the government’s Planning Inspectorate which will make the decision, expected in early October.
But City Hall’s planning team can still make representations and give advice, and it has now asked that the scheme is refused. In its submissions, Bristol City Council said: “It is concluded that the development would give rise to unacceptable traffic conditions and would fail to provide an appropriate level of safe, secure, accessible, and usable parking.
“Based on the level of detail provided, the development would also harm residential amenity and the character of the locality as a result of levels of on-street parking that cannot be reasonably accommodated on the surrounding streets.
“The application is considered unacceptable and it is recommended it is refused on this basis. The proposed increase in the number of bedrooms at the site means parking demand is likely to exceed existing capacity on nearby streets.”


It said the council’s transport officers were concerned that increased parking congestion would result in more drivers parking on pavements and near junctions, putting pedestrians at risk and reducing visibility.
A previous similar application in 2022 was refused by the local authority on road safety grounds. Transport officers disputed a parking survey by the applicants as part of that submission which did not comply with the council’s methods, which ban counting spaces on the opposite side of classified roads without pedestrian crossings.
They have also highlighted nearby road accidents which resulted in casualties – a total of 14 people hurt in the past eight years. The council said: “Despite several requests, the applicant did not submit a revised parking survey and no parking survey has been submitted to support the current application.”
However, it said it was satisfied that there would be no harmful loss of community facilities from the site, with the existing use – the 15-bed care home that has been vacant since January 2020 – being replaced by a similar level of health, social and welfare benefits.
The applicants’ agents said in planning documents that the two new HMOs at the pair of semi-detached Victorian villas would not exceed the council’s policy limits on how many there were in the area.
They said: “The site has not been in use for approximately five years and the proposal would allow this large building to be brought back into active use, while also improving its visual appearance and subsequently its contribution to the character and appearance of the conservation area.
“The proposal for two large HMOs is deemed appropriate for the application site and mixed-use context in view of its highly sustainable location on a main road and opposite the defined town centre.”
They said the building could not be modernised to meet current regulations for care homes so it could not be used again for this purpose.