New Bristol shopping street car ban tipped to fast-track end of Clean Air Zone charges

Banning through-traffic from Park Street could lead to Bristol’s Clean Air Zone being removed a year earlier than projected. Next Thursday Greens on Bristol City Council will try to push through their controversial plans for the shopping street in a bid to free up buses from traffic.

After Helen Godwin, the Labour mayor of the West of England, refused to fund the traffic plan, the council could instead use £8 million of income from the Clean Air Zone and £5.3 million from a government air quality grant. The mayor feared air pollution worsening on nearby roads, and suggested a trial scheme instead only operating at peak hours instead of around the clock.

But air quality experts say removing through-traffic from Park Street would actually reduce pollution from probably the most polluted part of Bristol. Nitrogen dioxide levels at Colston Avenue have stayed stubbornly above legal limits. If the Park Street plan goes ahead, some drivers would use a different route, with air pollution levels predicted to fall faster.

Bristol's Clean Air Zoneplaceholder image
Bristol's Clean Air Zone | BristolWorld

This would mean that the Clean Air Zone would hit its target a year sooner than previously thought. The government urged the council to roll out the Clean Air Zone to get nitrogen dioxide levels below the legal limit of 40 micrograms per cubic metre of air. Once this target is reached, the council could remove the zone and stop charging drivers of polluting vehicles who enter.

Green Councillor Ed Plowden, chair of the transport policy committee, said: “Moving forward with our plans for Park Street is forecasted to bring down by a year the time it will take us as a city to be compliant with air quality targets, which could allow the Clean Air Zone charge to be removed a year earlier than projected.

“This is because it has been modelled to reduce air pollution more quickly along Colston Avenue — the most problematic area within Bristol’s Clean Air Zone.”

Nine councillors on the transport policy committee will vote on Thursday, February 5, whether to press ahead with the Park Street plan. There are four Greens on the committee, three Labour councillors, one Conservative councillor and one Liberal Democrat. The Tories and Lib Dems are opposing the scheme, so the Greens need Labour to either support or abstain on the vote.

Labour councillors are understood to be discussing what to do, and share the mayor’s concerns about the impact on air pollution outside hospitals. The last time the committee voted on Park Street — when they approved the plan getting sent for the West of England Combined Authority for approval — Labour abstained from the vote.

Liberal Democrat Cllr Nicholas Coombes, who sits on the transport committee, said: “Restricting access to Park Street is the wrong decision for Bristol. We opposed the plan when it was proposed by the former Labour mayor, we opposed it when the Green Party forced it through committee, and we oppose using Bristol City Council money to pay for it now.

“Diverting vehicles from Park Street makes lives harder for many businesses, residents and visitors, and it increases congestion on Park Row and Anchor Road. Newly published modelling confirms our warnings from last year — that this scheme would see air quality worsen outside the hospital.”

If the plan goes ahead, drivers would be diverted from the Bearpit past the Bristol Royal Infirmary before rejoining the route at the Triangle. This would run along Marlborough Street, Upper Maudlin Street and Park Row. An increase in air pollution next to the hospital is the key reason the mayor chose not to fund the scheme. But the council says this would be negligible.

And a raft of changes to these roads would help traffic flow better too. A right turn onto Dighton Street would be banned; the timings of traffic lights would be changed to increase capacity; and the right-turn lane approaching St Michael’s Hill would be extended. In theory, this would mean cars spending less time idling on the road outside the hospital, with less of an effect on pollution.

Air quality experts Kalaco, commissioned by the council, found that the Park Street scheme would reduce pollution along Colston Avenue, Lewins Mead and Rupert Street “taking a significant step toward compliance”. Along the alternative route past the BRI, pollution would see a “slight increase, significantly smaller in magnitude”, and still be below 40 micrograms.

What happens once Bristol’s air complies with pollution laws is unclear. The council could scrap the Clean Air Zone and stop charging drivers of polluting vehicles to enter the area around the city centre. But this would risk pollution shooting back up, although the hope is that many drivers have swapped their vehicles for less polluting ones. New cleaner electric buses will help, too.

Legal limits could also be tightened up. Once the magic number of 40 micrograms is reached, the government could in theory lower this, given evidence that nitrogen dioxide still harms people’s health below this level. But the prospect of removing a £9 daily charge for thousands of drivers would be tempting for the city’s politicians, particularly given the cost of living crisis.

In the meantime, according to Kalaco, air quality levels will fall below 40 micrograms at Colston Avenue in 2027 if the Park Street scheme goes ahead, or 2028 if not. The Clean Air Zone needs to be in place for a year showing compliant levels of air quality, before it can be legally removed. However modelling is never perfect and pollution levels can be impacted by weather conditions.

In 2024 the average nitrogen dioxide levels of Colston Avenue were 48.7 micrograms. Along Park Row, Upper Maudlin Street and Marlborough Street, levels were between 20 and 29.3 micrograms. As well as diverting traffic, the Park Street scheme includes wider pavements and a new bike lane on Queens Road, encouraging more people to walk, cycle or take the bus.

Last autumn councillors considered hiking the charges, to either £10, £12 or £14 a day, to deter more drivers from entering the zone and reduce pollution more quickly. This came after concerns that progress was slowing, and nitrogen dioxide levels were increasing on Colston Avenue. But the environment policy committee vetoed the fee hike due to a lack of modelling.

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice