Forest of Dean 12,000-home plan branded bonkers as Bristol commuters and windy roads slammed

A Gloucestershire council’s bid to meet a 12,000-home housing target by building up to two brand new towns as well as growing its historic market towns and villages has been blasted as “bonkers”.

Forest of Dean District Council agreed a new direction for its new blueprint for development from now until 2045 at their meeting on November 13.

A woodland near Cinderford in the Forest of Dean, Gloucestershireplaceholder image
A woodland near Cinderford in the Forest of Dean, Gloucestershire | Matt Cardy/Getty Images

Planners recommended combining the strategy of building one or two new settlements with infrastructure as well as concentrating new housing, employment and infrastructure investment in the Forest’s main towns and villages.

A woodland near Cinderford in the Forest of Dean, Gloucestershireplaceholder image
A woodland near Cinderford in the Forest of Dean, Gloucestershire | Matt Cardy/Getty Images

They believe this will provide social benefits including new, well-designed communities with attractive, well-connected places with all necessary amenities and services.

These new settlements could be planned to include new schools, healthcare facilities and public spaces.

And they can increase affordable housing supply to help meet diverse housing needs.

No sites or allocations have yet to be decided. However, there are concerns the district’s geographical constraints mean it is more than likely the new towns would be built near junction 2 of the M50 close to Redmarley.

Or somewhere between the A48 and A40 near Churcham.

And there are fears such developments would lead to the creation of commuter towns while destroying the local character of the area.

Council leader Adrian Birch (G, Tidenham) said it was an important stage in the plan making and may be the last opportunity for residents to really have their say amid the impending local government reorganisation.

Adrian Birch, leader of Forest of Dean District Councilplaceholder image
Adrian Birch, leader of Forest of Dean District Council | Green Party/LDRS

“The preferred strategy sets out our spatial approach to identifying the housing employment and community development required and to meet local needs,” he said.

“It will shape the distribution of development across the district to deliver the additional housing requirement mandated by the government.

“What it does not do at this stage in the local plan timetable agreed by full council is fix any sites or any locations. This is for a later session.”

Councillor Jamie Elsmore (Progressive Independents, Berry Hill) raised concerns about the increased carbon footprint there would be by creating new towns as it would lead to an increase in commuters.

He said did not understand the logic of the Green Party cabinet.

“When you consider that we’ve got huge industrial sites at Coleford, Lydney and Cinderford, surely the logic with any residential home to reduce your carbon footprint is to have built residential homes near the biggest areas which offer employment,” he said.

“We are on a global path for zero carbon. We are also telling our farmers we need to be more self-sufficient in growing our own crops.

“But the proposal is to have a new settlement in the countryside which will reduce our ability to have our own crops.

“You’ve got an increased carbon footprint. Those people living in the new settlement will have to travel back to the industrial area.

“I don’t understand the logic.”

Cllr Birch said the council would have to look very closely at where they build the new settlements.

He also said there are many empty business properties in the three towns Cllr Elsmore mentioned.

“We have to recognise that as things stand at present the demand of our cities is such that people in the south and north of the district tend to commute out.

“I don’t particularly support that view but there is no way we can avoid that.”

He said the infrastructure needs to be in place before new settlements are developed.

Councillor Ian Whitburn (I, Coleford) said the strategy was “absolutely bonkers” and what is needed is council housing.

He said there needs to be “local houses for local people, not houses for people who want to move from Bristol.

“Let’s take all of the housing allocation off Bristol and Gloucester and put it in the Forest of Dean where there are no jobs, no infrastructure and the roads are already awful.

“We’ve got little windy roads to get in and out of the Forest .

“It’s ridiculous getting out to Gloucester, it’s ridiculous getting out to Chepstow to go to Bristol.

“It’s awful, this is all developer led. We’d all support houses for local people but these are not.”

He said the council was being asked to vote on a plan for one or two new towns and councillors don’t know where they will go.

“As we’ve heard before, we can’t build a supermarket, a road or anything until we’ve got the houses there,” he said.

“So in the meantime those people who do move into those new houses will have to go and work, shop and send their kids somewhere else.”

He said the Forest was already suffering due to inadequate water infrastructure.

“Honestly, this is bonkers. I cannot support this,” he said. “I can’t believe the Green-led administration would want to build on open green fields.

“We should all, every single authority like us, stand up to the government and say this is bonkers.

“Leave us alone. We cannot take this amount of housing at all.”

Councillor John Francis (I, Longhope and Huntley) said the need for social housing was in the east of the district not the west.

He questioned why employers would invest in the Forest towns and “nice new shiny” industrial sites are put on the edge of the district,” he said.

Reform UK councillor Stuart Graham (Cinderford East) said there are developers who are currently not sticking to their approved plans.

And Councillor Trevor Roach (G, Mitcheldean, Ruardean and Drybrook ) said the council is having to meet a target which is almost double the previous requirement of around 6,000 homes.

“I feel as if there is a belief there is a magic wand somewhere in this room and the Green Party are hiding it because we are the bad guys,” he said.

“It was hard enough to find locations for 6,500 homes. We’ve again heard in this chamber this evening not in my backyard, not Beachley, not north, not in the middle, so where are these 12,000 homes going to go? Where is this magic wand?”

He said he had to support the hybrid strategy as it was the most pragmatic option.

The council voted to approve the strategy by 19 votes in favour, 15 against and one abstention.

There will be a further debate on which sites are considered.

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice