Decision delayed on six-storey flats next to cottages and retirement complex in Bristol
A decision on the construction of six-storey flats next to cottages and a retirement complex in a Bristol area have been postponed to address concerns over height and proximity.
A decision has been delayed on permitting a block of flats next to old cottages and a retirement complex at the top of Whiteladies Road. Developers are planning to build two blocks of flats with 60 new homes and 209 square metres of office space.


But neighbours next to the site are concerned that the buildings will be too close to their homes and too tall. Bristol City Council previously refused permission for very similar plans back in 2021, which were also refused by the government’s Planning Inspectorate in 2023.
Now the developers, Elizabeth Blackwell Properties, have applied again to build the two blocks. One is slightly taller than the previous plans, and further away from a neighbouring building — but now also closer to other homes, sparking similar concerns as a few years ago.


One block would be four storeys tall and the other would be six storeys. Councillors on the development control B committee voted to delay making a decision on Wednesday, October 8. Instead they will visit the site to see for themselves how close the new buildings would be to neighbouring properties.
Stephen Johnson, a resident of the Vincent, said: “This new application is basically the same as the application refused by the Planning Inspectorate, who considered the proposed buildings to be overbearing, dominating and towering over adjoining cottages on St Vincent’s Hill. To address the inspector’s concerns on the height of Block B, the applicant has made two changes.
“The height of the proposed building has been increased from five to six storeys. How this addresses the inspector’s concerns is baffling. Block B has been moved closer to Queen Victoria House. This creates an overbearing effect on residents and the consequent loss of privacy will adversely affect their amenity.”
Audrey Remmert, who lives in St Vincent’s Hill, added: “Please do not condemn my home to a permanent sense of overbearing enclosure. Please refuse this scheme until a design is brought forward that genuinely meets Bristol’s standards and safeguards the amenities of our homes.”
Cottages next to the planned blocks are listed, and the site is within a conservation area supposed to protect the views of historic buildings. But on the other hand, 12 of the homes would be affordable and Clifton has some of the highest housing costs across Bristol.
Georgina Nelson, a planning agent representing developers, said: “While the appeal was dismissed, the inspector confirmed that the development was acceptable in all aspects, apart from the outlook on two properties. The proposals will deliver many benefits, including affordable housing and financial contributions to improving bus stops.”
The site is currently home to a small office building, a terrace of four houses, a bungalow, garages and a car park with 29 spaces. These buildings would be demolished if the plans go ahead.


Councillors chose not to visit the site before the committee meeting. But Greens then said they would need to see the location for themselves before deciding, as they were swayed by members of the public speaking during the meeting. This was criticised by Labour councillors, who suggested a visit should have been organised beforehand, to prevent delaying a decision.
There was also confusion about delaying a decision to organise a site visit. Unlike other places, the council has strict rules in place preventing development control committees from immediately voting to refuse planning permission.
This is because of longstanding concerns that the council was losing lots of money, when developers appealed their decision to the government’s Planning Inspectorate, which overturned many refusals. Instead, councillors must ask planning officers to come back to the next meeting with legally defensible reasons to refuse permission.
However, some councillors believe that this means they are hamstrung and the new rules are too onerous. They also said the Local Government Ombudsman had issued a draft notice that these rules are too strict and should be changed.
Green Councillor Guy Poultney said: “It deprives the committee of the ability to amend the motion and to suggest alternatives, just as the ombudsman said we were required to. We should be able to do more than this. But we’ve put in place a protocol that ties our hands.”
.png?width=96&crop=1:1,smart)