I tried the new menu at Bristol's posh Miller & Carter Steakhouse - but left feeling confused

It's a place I've always heard good things about, and Miller & Carter's new menu finally gave me an excuse to visit.

Upon entry, I couldn’t help but notice it really is a grand venue, with the Marriott Hotel foyer on College Green taking you through to the steakhouse.

With the golden, brown and red colour scheme, it was a fancy environment and I looked forward to seeing if the food matched.

For January, the restaurant has launched its new Rare Treats menu, which has been extended through to February 7. It’s not too pricey either, with two courses for £25.95 and three courses for £29.95.

placeholder image
BristolWorld

Now I’m someone who’s used to eating a supermarket steak and oven chips, so it was delightful to try something a bit more elaborate.

With the waitress coming up to serve me dressed in a waistcoat, I hoped that this style of presentation would carry over into the food, and I was largely not disappointed.

For starters, I had the prawn cocktail, made up of juicy king prawns, fresh gem lettuce and a punchy Bloody Mary sauce, which gave the dish a nice lift.

Impressed by the starter, I then went on to order the main - a steak of course, with the menu having steps to let you customise it.

placeholder image
BristolWorld

I went for the Black Angus prime rump 7oz - the only one with no supplementary charges which seemed to be a running theme through the menu.

I asked for it to be medium rare, with a sauce of beef dripping, a wedge dressing of spicy burnt chili and crispy onions, and a side of seasoned fries.

Now this is the bit where I got a bit confused because the lettuce wedge was served before my steak. I wasn’t sure if I was supposed to wait until the steak came out or not, but I stuck into it anyway.

I’ve now learnt that I was right to eat the wedge beforehand because apparently it’s to freshen up your palate so you can enjoy the flavours of the steak more. Who would have guessed?

The lettuce wedge confused meplaceholder image
The lettuce wedge confused me | BristolWorld

Not long after the steak came out with the fries and sauce. And while the steak was delicious, the sauce had a flavour that was almost like chicken soup and not particularly pleasant.

I found out after the meal that it was because I had accidentally been given the peppercorn sauce, which my partner had ordered, while they had had mine.

Nonetheless, I proceeded to dip the chips into the sauce - not sure if that was the right etiquette - and enjoyed the meal.

The standout was obviously the steak, which was cooked just right and full of flavour, although a bit on the small side.

I left the restaurant full, but a bit confused because of the lettuce wedge and sauce situation. At least I will now know what I am doing next time.

Related topics:
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice